Humanity is violent. Why single out Pirates?


Pirates are not unique in their use of violence. They are often are viewed as the villain in the story, but the truth is everyone is the villain. The wealthy, the noble, the holy, the politicians were all using violence, torture, brutality to force their will. They were all humans who hurt other humans. Sometimes joining as one force in a hateful, homicidal cause.

The human race has a savage history. From the crusades and Spanish Inquisition to Colonialism, Privateering, tribal wars and sexual abuse by the afore mentioned groups, our species has demonstrated ruthlessness across class, race, religion, and age.

Until recent history people have not been going to therapy nor restraining their impulses and communicating their feelings. Studies show those raised in violent environments or who are abused perpetuate a standard of violence. While this is true in childhood abuse cases it is also relevant if a whole society is living in danger and experiencing trauma as a component of daily life.

Humans are animals. We have certain instincts wired in or brain because we have been living in a more dangerous environment. In the time span of evolution we have lived hundred thousands of years in the wild at the mercy of ecological disasters, scarcities, and predator/ prey relationships. Under the threatening conditions of nature either you kill or be killed. You protect or take food, shelter, water or you become nutrients for the next life. You are fighting for your most basic needs to be met.

We have constructed a civilization of rules and eliminated the predator threat either through development of weapons or the effect our industrial physical destruction of natural habitats had on animal populations. Through these mechanisms and advancements in medicine and technology our society has been able to globally attain physiological and safety needs for a large portion of people. According to Maslow’s Heirarchy of Needs this base level must be met before the needs of love, a sense of connection, respect, friendship, or desire to be one’s best self can be met.

In the 21st century a larger percent of the population is existing where resources do not feel threatened, so we have different values and expectations of community to reflect this.

The culture and environment during the Golden Age of Piracy in the 17th and 18th century was more cutthroat and deadly than our society today. Therefore we cannot expect people of this time, including pirates, to the current laws and views on violence. The code of conduct of this time period was violence. The pirate code was violent as were the laws and punishments of the European governments on its citizens.

Sources:
Roser, Max. “War and Peace.” Our World in Data, 13 Dec. 2016, ourworldindata.org/war-and-peace.
Cordingly, David. Under The Black Flag. Harcourt Brace & Co., 1995.
Stockton, Frank R. Buccaneers and Pirates. Dover Publications, 2007.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Christopher Columbus Hero or Villain?

Image
American public school teaches that Christopher Columbus and other “explorers” were benevolent “discoverers”, sailing the seas on behalf of their sovereigns, in search of knowledge and resources. As a young students we learned cute rhymes like, “In 1492 Columbus sailed the ocean blue”.   Around Thanksgiving half our class donned tea stained fringed frocks and feather headbands and the other half buckled hats and loafers. We sat at the lunchroom table simulating the peaceful breaking of bread and cooperation between the indigenous people and European colonizers. While it is historically accurate that the settlers of Plymouth Rock celebrated the successful harvest of 1621 with members of the Wampanoag tribe, it is untrue that the “explorers” of the Americas treated the native peoples or their land with respect. Explorers invaded land, stole resources such as precious metals and jewels, massacred entire indigenous populations, and sold millions more into slavery. T...
Read more

Pirate Progressives

European monarchs inaccurately portrayed acts of violence committed by pirates disproportionate to the violence of 18 th century Europe during the Golden age of Piracy, thus creating a historical narrative that omitted the unprecedented and enlightened contributions of pirates. Painting a barbaric image of pirates benefitted the economic and political interest of governments as a way to distract from their own heinous acts. These governments and monarchies commissioned privateers to steal from opposing countries but denounce the pirates when they received political backlash. Pirates are vilified for using violence and torture though all governments, religious bodies, and citizens of the Golden Age of Piracy used equally cruel and gruesome methods. The egalitarian pirate code of conduct, cooperation among fleets, and contribution to the New World depict pirates as liberal patriots of a society much ahead of its time.
Read more

Blackbeard

Image
Journal of James Alexander October 14, 1717 I have been a shipmate on Hornigold's ship for about 8 months now.  A fierce lookin’ fella called  Edward Teach began as an apprentice today. I sketched him to the right. Bunking next to me but I don’t mind as he’s a quick study. We are heading to Delaware to meet another ship and sail around the Chesapeake Bay area to plunder trade and fishing ships coming into the area. Either way I have a mast to repair before we face winter. Almost lights out so I’ll be heading to bed now. November 7, 1717             We met up with Stede Bonny and crew. Solid to work with and we have more man power. Old Blackbeard is quite the character and Honrigold has taken to him as well. Tomorrow the crew votes on the destination of our new expedition. I am hoping we head south. Tis winter up here is much too windy and cold for me. I am not sure I can take another snow on deck. Plus ...
Read more